Advice
Stop Waiting for Certainty: Why Uncertainty is Your Biggest Business Advantage
Related Reading:
Here's something that'll ruffle a few feathers: uncertainty isn't your enemy. It's your competitive advantage.
I've been consulting to Australian businesses for over seventeen years now, and I can tell you with absolute conviction that the companies thriving right now aren't the ones with the most detailed five-year plans. They're the ones who've learnt to surf the chaos instead of fighting it.
Most business advice about uncertainty is complete bollocks. "Create contingency plans!" they shout. "Develop scenario planning!" Right, because that worked so well during COVID. I watched CEOs in Melbourne and Sydney with their beautiful colour-coded risk matrices completely lose their minds when the real world decided their spreadsheets were fiction.
The truth? Uncertainty has always been the default state of business. Always. We just pretended otherwise during the easy decades.
The Mythology of Control (And Why It's Killing Your Business)
Let me share something embarrassing. Back in 2018, I told a client in Perth to diversify their supply chain "just in case something happened in China." Smart advice, right? Except I was thinking about trade wars, not global pandemics. Even when you're right about uncertainty, you're usually wrong about what form it'll take.
That's the first lesson: stop trying to predict specific uncertainties. It's like trying to guess which particular wave will knock you off your surfboard. You don't prepare for the wave - you develop better balance.
I've noticed something fascinating about successful Australian business leaders over the years. They don't spend endless hours in strategy meetings talking about "what-if scenarios." Instead, they build what I call "uncertainty muscles" - capabilities that work regardless of what chaos shows up next.
Here's where most consultants get it backwards: they treat uncertainty as a problem to solve. But uncertainty isn't a bug in the system. It's a feature. Companies like Atlassian didn't succeed despite uncertainty - they succeeded because they learnt to leverage it whilst their competitors were paralysed by analysis.
The Three Types of Business Leaders (And Why Two of Them Fail)
After watching hundreds of leaders navigate crises, I've identified three distinct types. The first type - let's call them the Controllers - believe they can eliminate uncertainty through better planning. These are the folks who respond to every surprise by creating more processes. They're usually very smart people, but they exhaust their teams and themselves trying to control the uncontrollable.
The second type are the Panickers. They freeze when things get unpredictable. They call emergency meetings about everything, change direction weekly, and create more uncertainty through their reactions than the original problem ever did. I've seen entire departments quit because their leader couldn't handle not knowing what comes next.
But the third type? The Adapters. These legends don't fight uncertainty - they dance with it.
The best example I can give you is from a manufacturing client in Adelaide. When supply chain issues hit, instead of spending weeks creating elaborate backup plans, their MD simply said: "Right, what can we make with what we have today?" Within a month, they'd pivoted to producing something completely different, retained all their staff, and actually increased revenue. Their competitors were still in meetings discussing contingency frameworks.
Why Your Brain Hates Uncertainty (And How to Retrain It)
Here's something they don't teach you in business school: our brains are wired to hate uncertainty. Evolution programmed us to see uncertainty as danger. That rustling bush might be wind, or it might be a predator. Better safe than sorry.
The problem is, in modern business, that rustling bush is usually just wind. But our prehistoric brains haven't got the memo.
This is where emotional intelligence for managers becomes crucial. You need to recognise when your brain is catastrophising versus when there's actual danger. Most uncertainty feels urgent but isn't actually important.
I've started teaching my clients a simple question: "Is this uncertainty something I need to respond to today, or is my brain just uncomfortable with not knowing?"
Roughly 73% of the time, it's the latter.
The Uncertainty Advantage: Why Chaos Creates Opportunity
Here's my second controversial opinion: uncertain times are actually the best times to grow your business. Everyone else is hiding under their desks, which means there's less competition for everything - talent, customers, market share, media attention.
Think about it. When everyone's scared, who stands out? The person who's not scared. Or at least, the person who acts despite being scared.
During the 2008 financial crisis, whilst other consulting firms were cutting costs and laying people off, I hired three new consultants and expanded into Brisbane. Best business decision I ever made. Not because I wasn't scared - I was terrified - but because I realised that sitting still was actually the riskier option.
This is where traditional risk management gets it arse-backwards. They focus on minimising downside risk but ignore opportunity risk - the risk of missing out whilst you're busy planning.
The Daily Practice of Uncertainty Tolerance
Building uncertainty tolerance isn't about meditation or mindfulness apps (though they don't hurt). It's about practical daily habits that strengthen your ability to act without complete information.
First habit: make at least one decision daily with incomplete information. Start small. Choose a restaurant without reading reviews. Take a different route to work. Buy something without researching it to death first.
Second habit: celebrate the unexpected. When something surprises you at work, instead of immediately trying to prevent it happening again, ask: "What can this teach us?" Some of my best business innovations came from things going wrong in interesting ways.
Third habit: practice saying "I don't know, but here's what I think we should try." Most leaders think admitting uncertainty makes them look weak. Actually, pretending to know everything when nobody knows anything makes you look like a fool.
When Uncertainty Becomes Office Politics
One thing nobody talks about: uncertainty brings out the absolute worst in workplace politics. When people are scared, they start protecting territory, hoarding information, and throwing colleagues under buses.
I've seen uncertainty tear apart previously cohesive teams because nobody addressed the fear directly. Instead, they held "alignment meetings" and created "communication frameworks" whilst trust evaporated in real time.
The solution isn't more meetings. It's more honesty. As a leader, your job isn't to eliminate uncertainty - it's to model how to function effectively despite it.
Here's what I tell my leadership coaching clients: your team doesn't need you to have all the answers. They need you to demonstrate that not having answers isn't the end of the world.
The Australian Advantage (Yes, We Actually Have One)
Australians are naturally better at handling uncertainty than most other cultures. We've got this cultural saying: "She'll be right." While Americans are creating disaster recovery plans, we're usually just getting on with it.
This isn't about being reckless or unprepared. It's about understanding that excessive planning can be just another form of procrastination. Sometimes the best preparation is simply accepting that you can't prepare for everything.
I've worked with multinational companies where the Australian divisions consistently outperformed during uncertain periods, not because they had better plans, but because they had less attachment to their plans working perfectly.
What Actually Works (The Stuff They Don't Teach in MBA Programs)
After nearly two decades of watching businesses navigate uncertainty, here's what actually works:
Build redundancy, not prediction. Having multiple small revenue streams beats having one perfectly optimised one. Having team members who can do multiple jobs beats having specialists who can only do one thing brilliantly.
Focus on speed of response over quality of planning. The ability to try something, quickly see if it works, and pivot if it doesn't is worth more than months of strategic planning.
Invest in relationships during calm periods. When uncertainty hits, having strong relationships with customers, suppliers, and team members matters more than having perfect processes.
Create psychological safety around failure. Teams that can quickly admit when something isn't working adapt faster than teams that need to pretend everything's fine.
The Dirty Secret About Uncertainty
Here's what most business gurus won't tell you: some uncertainty is manufactured by the people who profit from your anxiety about it.
The financial media makes money from keeping you worried about what might happen. Consultants make money from selling you solutions to problems that might never occur. Software companies make money from selling you tools to track and predict everything.
I'm not saying ignore real risks. I'm saying question whether the uncertainty you're worried about is actually worth the mental energy you're spending on it.
Your Uncertainty Action Plan (Because Everyone Expects One)
Right, if you've read this far, you're probably thinking: "This is all very philosophical, but what do I actually do on Monday morning?"
Fair point. Here's your practical uncertainty toolkit:
Start each week by identifying one assumption your business is making that might be wrong. Question one "that's just how we do things" belief. Most business assumptions are just historical accidents that nobody's bothered to revisit.
Create an "uncertainty budget" - allocate specific time and resources for experimenting with new approaches. Treat it like R&D for resilience.
Build "uncertainty conversations" into your team meetings. Not risk assessment meetings - uncertainty conversations. What don't we know? What are we assuming? What would we do if our biggest assumption turned out to be wrong?
Stop rewarding people for being right and start rewarding them for being useful when they're wrong.
The thing about uncertainty is that it's not actually uncertain whether it'll show up. It definitely will. The only uncertainty is whether you'll be ready for it.
More Resources: